Trade - Costanzo

[DJBrooks]

https://niagaraicedogs.net/article/t...ded-to-windsor

What a disaster......my god

[Dogs Enthusiast 104]

That is a shame. I liked watching him play.

[5 for fighting]

Wow, the Icedogs drafted him 23rd overall in the 2021 draft. Then after his rookie season, they give him away for a 4th round pick and a 12th round pick. The Icedogs didn’t just lose this trade, they were completely embarrassed by the trade. I think this could be the worst trade the Icedogs have ever made. Yes, even worse then trading a 4th round pick for Gaidamak and then revealing that he isn’t coming to play for the Icedogs.

[fishfan51]

Ohhhh, bad trade.

[hockey123]

Originally Posted by 5 for fighting

Wow, the Icedogs drafted him 23rd overall in the 2021 draft. Then after his rookie season, they give him away for a 4th round pick and a 12th round pick. The Icedogs didn’t just lose this trade, they were completely embarrassed by the trade. I think this could be the worst trade the Icedogs have ever made. Yes, even worse then trading a 4th round pick for Gaidamak and then revealing that he isn’t coming to play for the Icedogs.

Aaron Snow says hi.

I guess it depends on how he develops. Joey clearly liked him more than DeDobbelaer does. I was pretty excited when they drafted him thinking maybe the had a big time tender to build with.

[strohs]

Originally Posted by fishfan51

Ohhhh, bad trade.

Can it get any worse?

I am not saying he would be the second coming of Mark Visentin but clearly IMO he gave up way too soon on this player. If the return was a deal too good to refuse then sure make it but wow this is underwhelming.

For all of JBs warts, I always thought he was the far superior of the two brothers in their roles, man I cannot believe I am saying this, ok I will not say what I was going to say lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[OlDawg]

Originally Posted by 5 for fighting

Wow, the Icedogs drafted him 23rd overall in the 2021 draft. Then after his rookie season, they give him away for a 4th round pick and a 12th round pick. The Icedogs didn’t just lose this trade, they were completely embarrassed by the trade. I think this could be the worst trade the Icedogs have ever made. Yes, even worse then trading a 4th round pick for Gaidamak and then revealing that he isn’t coming to play for the Icedogs.

Joey Costanzo now has 19 Ws with Windsor & they are good bets to get to the OHL finals. . We know that DDD needs to fire his GM
when you see this kind of trade going down. Joey, in his sophomore year, was given coaching & a team to play behind.
Couldn't have that in Niagara.

[strohs]

Originally Posted by OlDawg

Joey Costanzo now has 19 Ws with Windsor & they are good bets to get to the OHL finals. . We know that DDD needs to fire his GM
when you see this kind of trade going down. Joey, in his sophomore year, was given coaching & a team to play behind.
Couldn't have that in Niagara.

He certainly would not have got 19 W with this team but I agree with the sentiment of your post

There was no need to trade him IMO given his young age and unknown how he would have developed in his second year in the league

Instead he overpays for an older below average goalie

Like many of his trades there simply was no need for it other than he probably wanted his own guys which apparently he has terrible experience at selecting thee players to be any good


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[dogs777]

Originally Posted by strohs

He certainly would not have got 19 W with this team but I agree with the sentiment of your post

There was no need to trade him IMO given his young age and unknown how he would have developed in his second year in the league

Instead he overpays for an older below average goalie

Like many of his trades there simply was no need for it other than he probably wanted his own guys which apparently he has terrible experience at selecting thee players to be any good


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Forget the Flores trade for a second since that was the first trade of the two (if I remember correctly) why are we giving up on the younger guy instead of a guy who I personally never liked and is an OA next year which means chances are he’s not around.

[strohs]

Originally Posted by dogs777

Forget the Flores trade for a second since that was the first trade of the two (if I remember correctly) why are we giving up on the younger guy instead of a guy who I personally never liked and is an OA next year which means chances are he’s not around.

The Flores trade was part two of the trade

It made the first trade which initially looked great look not so great

But yes I do agree with you otherwise why give up on the younger goalie who was a second round pick and then bring in another below average or average older goalie

Pure stupidity IMO


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk